Magnolia vs Crafter CMS
Compare Magnolia and Crafter CMS for your content needs. Find out what actual users are saying about each product and which one is best suited for you!
What Users Say
See what users who have used Magnolia and Crafter CMS have to say about their overall experience with the product.
Magnolia's Key Strengths
Read what users love about Magnolia.
Crafter CMS's Key Strengths
Read what users love about Crafter CMS.
Magnolia's Key Issues
Read what issues users have with Magnolia.
Crafter CMS's Key Issues
Read what issues users have with Crafter CMS.
What Marketers & Content Creators Say
Hear from the users who uses Magnolia and Crafter CMS daily about their experience with the editors.
Magnolia's Editorial Experience Highlights
What marketers love about Magnolia's editor.
Crafter CMS's Editorial Experience Highlights
What marketers love about Crafter CMS's editor.
Magnolia's Editorial Experience Issues
What marketers dislike about Magnolia's editor.
Crafter CMS's Editorial Experience Issues
What marketers dislike about Crafter CMS's editor.
Mobile Editing
Find out how the platforms handle the mobile-first experience for the new generation of workforce on the move.
Magnolia CMS supports mobile-first experience with a focus on creating content on mobile devices.
"Focused on delivering modern UX designs with a mobile-first mindset."Source
"Start building responsive, mobile-first experience sites using web components with React, Angular or Vue."Source
"Focus then shifted to mobile first, omni-channel experience, personalisation, loyalty and analytics."Source
"Their rebuild of the software for a tablet and mobile first design."Source
Craft CMS does not support a dedicated mobile-first content creation experience; desktop usage is recommended.
Automatic Content Linking
Find out if the platform supports automatic linking of related content to help user discover more content without additional manual effort from the marketer. This automatically create topical clusters of content and is essential for SEO.
The feature of automatic related blog linking is unclear from the available documentation and sources.
Craft CMS does not support automatic linking of related blog content; manual relationships are required.
"Entries are flexible content containers... but do not support automatic linking of related content."Source
"Feature request for better auto-saving behavior shows Craft's focus on manual linking options."Source
"Craft CMS features highlight flexibility but lack mention of automatic related content linking."Source
Automatic CTA Linking
Find out if the platform supports automatic display of Call-to-Actions using AI to help users take actions that are relevant to the content they are reading.
Magnolia offers AI features that assist in automatic content creation, but specific CTA linking is not detailed.
"Magnolia’s AI Accelerator brings flexibility and composability to AI in digital experiences, by supporting connections to any generative AI engines to speed up content creation."Source
"Magnolia equips you with powerful tooling and an easy to use interface so that you can work more effectively and launch experiences faster."Source
"This feature was experimental and relied on outdated and unmaintained libraries."Source
The status of Automatic CTA Linking in Craft CMS remains unclear; sources provide no definitive confirmation.
Comments
Find out if the platform supports comments from your users to improve user engagement. This is often a great way to collect feedback and user emails.
Magnolia CMS supports commenting with moderation, email notifications, and anonymous comments.
"This module offers commenting features as well as the possibility of liking or disliking comments. You can moderate comments or mark as author’s favourite."Source
Built-in commenting with features like moderation, email notifications, and anonymous commenting support.
"Allow your users to comment on elements. Threaded comments - users can comment on other comments. Comment moderation by admins - prevent comments from appearing on your site until approved."Source
"Comment on any element – whether it be an entry, product or event. Threaded comments. Email Notifications for element authors when someone posts a comment."Source
Multi-tenancy
Find out if the platform supports managing multiple clients or projects within a single account. This is useful for agencies, multi-client or multi-project scenarios.
Magnolia supports multi-tenancy, allowing agencies to manage multiple client sites with separate configurations.
"Multi-tenancy and the ability to share content assets - while also being able to configure access on a per-tenant basis - is crucial in today's..."Source
"With Magnolia's multi-site, multi-language and multi-tenancy capabilities, you can centrally manage your network of franchises, country sites or subsidiary websites."Source
"Using the Multisite module, you can set up and run multiple websites with different domains and languages from one Magnolia installation."Source
Craft CMS supports multi-tenancy, allowing multiple sites from a single installation.
What Developers Say
Hear from developers who've integrated and built on Magnolia and Crafter CMS about their experiences.
Magnolia's DX Highlights
What developers love about building with Magnolia.
Crafter CMS's DX Highlights
What developers love about building with Crafter CMS.
Magnolia's DX Issues
What developers dislike about building with Magnolia.
Crafter CMS's DX Issues
What developers dislike about building with Crafter CMS.
Content Modelling
Find out how developers model and manage their content with the platform with key highlights and limitations.
Magnolia CMS supports content modelling with customizable content types and properties.
"Magnolia allows you to manage all your content and media in one place. Flexible content modeling."Source
"A content model defines the structure and attributes of content for a specific project, including content types."Source
"The Magnolia Content Types module is a tool to define the content model in Magnolia, creating a shared understanding across the domains."Source
"A model definition describes the properties of a content type, including fields and relationships."Source
Craft CMS supports content modeling with custom fields and types, offering flexibility and built-in options for various content structures.
"Craft provides a number of distinct building blocks, each appropriate for different kinds of content. We use the term elements to collectively describe the variety of content types Craft comes with."Source
"Craft CMS gives you flexibility and control throughout the entire content modeling and editing process."Source
"New CLI commands for taming your content model, a new Link field type, and more! We now have a total of 23 built-in custom field types."Source
"Craft is unique in that it is both a simple and a complex CMS. You can create the structure, fields, and all the forms without ever touching any code."Source
Custom React Components
Find out if the platform supports custom React components to go beyond the basic HTML components for content.
Custom React components are supported through the Magnolia React Editor allowing dynamic content management.
"The Magnolia React Editor provides a lightweight, fully-featured library connecting React projects with the WYSIWYG authoring experience."Source
"Magnolia React Templating allows you to use React JSX Components in Magnolia templates."Source
"Components render content entered by editors in dialogs, supporting nested components."Source
Craft CMS does not support embedding custom React components directly in the content editor.
"Craft's entire API is at your finger tips but does not mention the support for custom React components."Source
"Matrix fields allow you to manage nested entries but not specifically React components."Source
"Craft can act as a headless CMS and use GraphQL, but does not support React directly in the content editor."Source
Full Text Search
Find out if the platform supports full text search across multiple fields to help users find content quickly.
Fully supports full-text search across all content with real-time results customization.
"Magnolia’s search works using the Lucene algorithm where by default all properties mentioned in the index-rule receive a boost value of 1.0."Source
"The Find Bar allows you to search across all content search inside and outside Magnolia (federated search, enterprise search). The search covers all Magnolia and custom-content apps, assets and pages."Source
"It offers powerful full-text search across all your content and provides a starting point for many tasks."Source
Craft CMS supports full text search across multiple fields, including advanced syntax for querying.
"Craft includes a system-wide search index used for finding elements via keywords."Source
"Craft CMS includes a system-wide search service used for finding elements via keyword search."Source
"Craft's full-text search based on the underlying database is powerful and the very best choice for the vast majority of users."Source
Starter Kits
Discover starter kits and templates to help you get started with the platform.
Magnolia CMS has several starter kits available for developers.
(Expand section to see a list of Magnolia templates and starter kits.)
Craft CMS offers several starter kits including starter projects and boilerplates.
(Expand section to see a list of Crafter CMS templates and starter kits.)
Pricing & Plans
Compare the prices of Magnolia and Crafter CMS.