Keystatic vs Crafter CMS

Offers first-class CMS experience with TypeScript and support for Markdown, YAML, and JSON.

Integrating Keystatic into an Astro blog is straightforward, and it allows coexistence of new and old content formats.

Rich text editing experience right out of the box with minimal setup.

Supports creating custom fields and components, enhancing the content management experience.

Allows connection to GitHub repositories and local file system for easy content management.

Markdown and JSON support simplifies the content workflow, appealing for technical users.

Craft CMS offers robust multilingual support and a powerful Matrix field type that allows for endless customization.

Craft CMS provides a better development experience with a clean canvas for template development compared to WordPress.

Craft’s custom fields and UI are praised for their intuitive design, making it easier to manage content types effectively.

Limited support for MDX content, which may hinder those with existing MDX setups.

Users may encounter difficulties when setting up environment variables for GitHub integration.

As it is still in experimental phases, users may face bugs or limitations.

The admin UI can become complex when trying to integrate with existing layouts.

Users have mentioned that not all features are fully developed, leading to missing functionalities.

Some advanced features may require more configuration than initially expected.

The Craft CMS update process is described as inconsistent and often problematic, causing frustration during updates.

Getting support for Craft and developer availability is limited compared to WordPress, making it more challenging to find help when needed.

Users cite difficulty with importing content into Craft, citing bugs that can lead to formatting issues in WYSIWYG fields.

The complexity of developing custom functionalities in Craft compared to WordPress is a common critique among developers.

Some developers express a preference for the Advanced Custom Fields (ACF) in WordPress, which they find more powerful and user-friendly than Craft's offerings.

The integration with Astro is seamless and allows for custom components.

Users appreciate the simple markdown interface that provides flexibility.

Markdown and JSON management allows for easy content updates without confusion.

The ease of managing content in markdown is highlighted.

Keystatic frequently saves drafts, which is helpful for users.

Customizability of the admin UI is frequently appreciated by developers.

Craft's author experience is exceptional, featuring a straightforward fields and sections structure that simplifies content management.

Craft's editor provides a side-by-side view that updates in real-time as content is edited, enhancing the authoring experience.

Craft's handling of entry relations is smoother than in WordPress, allowing for more intuitive linking of content.

Craft's built-in Feed Me component allows easy content import from various formats, simplifying data management for authors.

Craft allows for easy multi-site management and localization, which is less complex compared to other CMSs.

The database schema in Craft can be saved as a YAML file, allowing for easier environment synchronization during development.

Limited support for MDX format caused migration challenges for existing content.

Users faced difficulties with integrating images correctly in their posts.

Keystatic lacks some advanced features expected by users migrating from other CMS.

Users encountered issues with validations on the datetime field.

Some marketers find Craft's rigid structure a hindrance, as it requires developer intervention for content updates.

A common complaint is the lack of out-of-the-box SEO tools comparable to plugins like Yoast on WordPress.

Craft's customization can lead to complexity, and some users may feel overwhelmed by the features available to developers.

Despite Craft's advantages, its smaller community often limits the resources available compared to more established CMS platforms.

Some users report dissatisfaction with Craft's plugin ecosystem, particularly regarding support and updates for third-party plugins.

Critics mention Craft's pricing model as a barrier, as ongoing costs can accumulate significantly, especially for teams on a budget.

Integrating Keystatic with Astro was straightforward and didn't produce installation errors.

Keystatic successfully managed Markdown content without major issues during setup.

Users find Keystatic easy to configure, especially compared to alternatives like Tina CMS.

It is seen as a good git-based CMS with simple integration.

Keystatic allows simple content organization based on user-defined structures.

The blocks structure allows flexibility in building pages.

User-friendly interface for content creation, making it easier for non-technical users to adapt.

Craft allows for the integration of forms through plugins like Formie.

Customization is possible through thousands of available plugins and APIs.

High standards for plugins ensure reliability and security in integrations.

Real-time updates in the editing mode improve workflow.

MDX support was initially lacking, causing a shift to other content types.

Encountered difficulties when converting existing content formats and managing schema.

Users reported validation issues when using the admin UI, indicating potential schema misconfigurations.

One user encountered issues with accessing posts in the admin interface due to schema conflicts.

Some users expressed frustration with limited documentation and encountered initial setup issues.

Fewer plugins available compared to WordPress leading to limited out-of-the-box functionality.

The learning curve can be steep for new users.

Dependency on custom integrations for specific features may deter users.

Custom integrations might be needed for connecting to third-party services like Dynamics 365.

Some users consider the initial setup cumbersome despite powerful features.

Some features may require extensive development knowledge for proper implementation.