Payload CMS vs TinaCMS
Compare Payload CMS and TinaCMS for your content needs. Find out what actual users are saying about each product and which one is best suited for you!
What Users Say
See what users who have used Payload CMS and TinaCMS have to say about their overall experience with the product.
Payload CMS's Key Strengths
Read what users love about Payload CMS.
TinaCMS's Key Strengths
Read what users love about TinaCMS.
Payload CMS's Key Issues
Read what issues users have with Payload CMS.
TinaCMS's Key Issues
Read what issues users have with TinaCMS.
What Marketers & Content Creators Say
Hear from the users who uses Payload CMS and TinaCMS daily about their experience with the editors.
Payload CMS's Editorial Experience Highlights
What marketers love about Payload CMS's editor.
TinaCMS's Editorial Experience Highlights
What marketers love about TinaCMS's editor.
Payload CMS's Editorial Experience Issues
What marketers dislike about Payload CMS's editor.
TinaCMS's Editorial Experience Issues
What marketers dislike about TinaCMS's editor.
Mobile Editing
Find out how the platforms handle the mobile-first experience for the new generation of workforce on the move.
Payload CMS supports mobile-first experiences, allowing content creation on mobile devices seamlessly.
"It works seamlessly on desktop and mobile (still can't believe most headless CMS admin panels aren't responsive in 2022)."Source
"Payload will give you backend superpowers... even non-technical users can independently make use of its Admin Panel to manage whatever they need to without having to know code."Source
"Users in the Admin Panel have the ability to choose between light mode and dark mode for their editing experience."Source
TinaCMS has basic mobile editing capabilities but lacks a fully optimized mobile editor experience.
"Try Tina CMS, specifically with Tina cloud. I'm building a site out right now and the mobile editing experience is very straightforward."Source
"Using Tina to edit content is, unfortunately, where the rough edges start to show. I started trying to write this post on my phone... the interface is clearly not meant for mobile screen sizes."Source
"TinaCMS now supports various screen sizes and mobile devices, including iOS and Android. Whether you’re on the go, or at your desk, editing your content has never been more intuitive."Source
Automatic Content Linking
Find out if the platform supports automatic linking of related content to help user discover more content without additional manual effort from the marketer. This automatically create topical clusters of content and is essential for SEO.
Payload CMS requires manual linking using the Relationship field; automated linking for SEO is not available.
"One of the most straightforward ways to manage related content in Payload CMS is through the Relationship field. This feature allows you to link different documents together."Source
"By leveraging these relationship types, Payload CMS enables users to build complex content architectures that cater to a wide range of applications, from e-commerce sites to blogs with related posts."Source
"The Rich Text field features a Link element which allows for users to automatically reference related documents within their rich text."Source
TinaCMS does not include an automatic related blog feature for linking content. Manual linking is possible but not automated.
"Easiest CMS to set up with Astro : r/astrojs"Source
"I also use TinaCMS for writing Blog post but it's way better than Tina CMS."Source
"Each item in your collections array represents its own entity. In the above example, we defined a post collection."Source
"Defining "collections". In the above example, we defined a post collection, and set its path as content/posts."Source
Automatic CTA Linking
Find out if the platform supports automatic display of Call-to-Actions using AI to help users take actions that are relevant to the content they are reading.
Supports custom components but lacks dedicated automatic CTA linking functionality.
"All Custom Components in Payload are React Server Components by default. This enables the use of the Local API directly on the front-end."Source
"You can design and build your own Slate elements and leaves to extend the editor with your own functionality."Source
"You can use Relationships to link to existing documents within the Rich Text field."Source
TinaCMS does not support automatic linking of CTAs based on content; only manual linking is possible.
Comments
Find out if the platform supports comments from your users to improve user engagement. This is often a great way to collect feedback and user emails.
Payload CMS supports commenting via a dedicated plugin with features like comment approval and email alerts.
"A fully-customizable plugin for Payload CMS to create a collection for comments, reviews, or other user-submitted feedback."Source
"Implement a comment functionality where everyone can comment without logging in."Source
"The community discusses challenges and features of Payload, including the need for custom implementations."Source
TinaCMS does not offer built-in commenting feature for public content. Custom implementations are possible but not out-of-the-box.
Multi-tenancy
Find out if the platform supports managing multiple clients or projects within a single account. This is useful for agencies, multi-client or multi-project scenarios.
Payload CMS offers multi-tenancy via a plugin that enables hierarchical tenant management, domain mapping, and isolation.
"This plugin sets up multi-tenancy for your application from within your Admin Panel. It adds a `tenant` field to all specified collections."Source
"This plugin allows multiple tenants to access different resources in the same instance of Payload CMS."Source
"Payload's Access Control facilitated a multi-tenant, "subsite"-based system."Source
TinaCMS offers multi-tenancy capabilities but requires manual implementation for user management and project collaborations.
What Developers Say
Hear from developers who've integrated and built on Payload CMS and TinaCMS about their experiences.
Payload CMS's DX Highlights
What developers love about building with Payload CMS.
TinaCMS's DX Highlights
What developers love about building with TinaCMS.
Payload CMS's DX Issues
What developers dislike about building with Payload CMS.
TinaCMS's DX Issues
What developers dislike about building with TinaCMS.
Content Modelling
Find out how developers model and manage their content with the platform with key highlights and limitations.
Payload CMS supports content modeling with various field types including relationships, arrays, and blocks.
"Payload provides a wide variety of built-in Field Types, each with its own unique properties and behaviors."Source
"Payload allows parent/child content modelling using a nested docs plugin for hierarchical content."Source
"Each Collection can have its own unique Access Control, Hooks, Admin Options, and more."Source
TinaCMS supports content modeling, allowing custom content types and various fields.
"Tina uses a "content-modeling as code" approach, allowing developers to define the shape of their content."Source
"Tina contains multiple field types like string, number, boolean, image, object, etc. that help in content modeling."Source
"TinaCMS allows for real-time visual editing and has a robust content modeling schema that enhances block-based editing."Source
"TinaCMS provides flexible content modeling features allowing developers to create custom content types."Source
"Tina CMS is highlighted as a notable Git-based content management system that excels in content modeling."Source
Custom React Components
Find out if the platform supports custom React components to go beyond the basic HTML components for content.
Payload CMS supports custom React components through its admin panel, allowing rich interactive content.
TinaCMS supports custom React components via the ui.component property in field definitions.
"A custom component can be passed and rendered by setting the ui.component property on a field. This component completely overrides the original component."Source
"The first approach involves defining a React component and passing it into the component property of a field definition."Source
"Tina also provides a variety of pre-built components. To specify these, the ui.component property should be configured with the string name of the registered field plugin."Source
Full Text Search
Find out if the platform supports full text search across multiple fields to help users find content quickly.
Payload CMS supports full text search through the @payloadcms/plugin-search, enabling advanced search across various fields.
TinaCMS supports full text search using search-index allowing content searches across multiple fields.
"TinaCMS provides built-in search functionality for content. This is useful for allowing editors to quickly finding content in a site."Source
"Search is not currently supported in self-hosted Tina."Source
"The self-hosted backend does not currently have endpoints to support search functionality."Source
Starter Kits
Discover starter kits and templates to help you get started with the platform.
Payload CMS offers several starter kits, including an Ecommerce and a SvelteKit template.
(Expand section to see a list of Payload CMS templates and starter kits.)
TinaCMS offers starter kits for Next.js and Astro integration.
(Expand section to see a list of TinaCMS templates and starter kits.)
Pricing & Plans
Compare the prices of Payload CMS and TinaCMS.