Should I Use TanStack Query When Most of My Components Are Server Components?

You've embraced React Server Components in your application, leveraging their powerful server-side rendering capabilities. But now you're wondering: "Isn't most of the added value lost if we have server components?" This is a common concern echoing through the developer community, especially when considering whether to integrate TanStack Query into a server-component-heavy architecture.

The short answer? TanStack Query still offers significant value, even in applications predominantly using server components. Let's explore why and when you should consider using it.

Understanding the Dilemma

Modern React applications often combine both server and client components, creating a hybrid architecture that can sometimes feel complex to manage. While server components excel at initial data fetching and rendering, real-world applications frequently require more dynamic data interactions that happen after the initial page load.

Consider these common scenarios:

  • Opening a dialog to view detailed entity information

  • Implementing real-time updates for dynamic content

  • Managing complex state across multiple components

  • Handling non-serializable data from the server

  • Maintaining consistent URL states during pagination or filtering

These scenarios often demand more sophisticated state management than what server components alone can provide. This is where TanStack Query shines, even in a server-component-dominated application.

The Power of TanStack Query

TanStack Query isn't just another state management library - it's specifically designed to handle the complexities of server state in your application. Here's what makes it particularly valuable:

  1. Robust Caching System: TanStack Query provides an intelligent caching mechanism that can significantly improve your application's performance and user experience. Even with server components handling the initial data fetch, subsequent interactions can benefit from this caching layer.

  2. Automatic Background Updates: The library manages background data refreshing and revalidation, ensuring your UI stays in sync with server data without manual intervention.

  3. Complex State Management: It handles loading, error, and success states automatically, reducing boilerplate code and making your components cleaner and more maintainable.

  4. Optimistic Updates: When modifying data, TanStack Query allows you to update the UI immediately while handling the server communication in the background, creating a more responsive user experience.

Real-World Use Cases

Let's explore specific scenarios where TanStack Query proves invaluable, even in applications heavily utilizing server components.

1. Dynamic Dialog Content

When you need to open a dialog to view details about an entity, server components alone might not provide the best user experience. Here's how TanStack Query can help:

function EntityDetailsDialog({ entityId }) {
  const { data, isLoading, error } = useQuery({
    queryKey: ['entity', entityId],
    queryFn: () => fetchEntityDetails(entityId)
  });

  if (isLoading) return <LoadingSpinner />;
  if (error) return <ErrorMessage error={error} />;

  return (
    <Dialog>
      <DialogContent>
        <h2>{data.title}</h2>
        <p>{data.description}</p>
      </DialogContent>
    </Dialog>
  );
}

This approach provides smooth loading states and error handling while maintaining a responsive user interface.

2. Real-Time Updates

Many developers express the need to handle real-time data updates efficiently. As one developer noted in a Reddit discussion: "I just use it for fetching client side, but I'd like to go back through and use prefetch on the server because there are some instances where I need it server and client (mostly real-time stuff)."

TanStack Query makes this easier with its refetching capabilities:

function LiveDataComponent() {
  const { data } = useQuery({
    queryKey: ['liveData'],
    queryFn: fetchLiveData,
    refetchInterval: 5000 // Refetch every 5 seconds
  });

  return <div>{/* Render live data */}</div>;
}

3. URL State Management

For applications requiring pagination or filtering with URL state preservation, TanStack Query integrates seamlessly with URL parameters:

function ProductList() {
  const [searchParams] = useSearchParams();
  const page = searchParams.get('page') || '1';
  
  const { data, isLoading } = useQuery({
    queryKey: ['products', page],
    queryFn: () => fetchProducts(page),
    keepPreviousData: true // Smooth pagination experience
  });

  return (
    <div>
      {/* Render product list with pagination */}
    </div>
  );
}

Best Practices for Integration

When combining TanStack Query with server components, following these best practices will help you maximize the benefits while avoiding common pitfalls:

1. Selective Implementation

Don't feel pressured to use TanStack Query for every data fetching operation. As one developer wisely noted, "If it's possible to get the data on the server side, this should be done, without the help of Tanstack Query (except for prefetching)." Use it strategically where it adds the most value:

  • Dynamic data requirements

  • Client-side interactions

  • Real-time updates

  • Complex caching needs

2. Leverage Prefetching

TanStack Query's prefetching capabilities can bridge the gap between server and client components:

// In your server component
await queryClient.prefetchQuery({
  queryKey: ['data'],
  queryFn: () => fetchData()
});

// In your client component
function ClientComponent() {
  const { data } = useQuery({
    queryKey: ['data'],
    queryFn: () => fetchData()
  });
  
  return <div>{/* Render data */}</div>;
}

3. Handle Non-Serializable Data

When dealing with data that can't be serialized for server components, TanStack Query provides an elegant solution:

function DownloadComponent() {
  const { data } = useQuery({
    queryKey: ['binaryData'],
    queryFn: () => fetchBinaryData(),
    enabled: false // Only fetch when needed
  });

  return (
    <button onClick={() => queryClient.fetchQuery(['binaryData'])}>
      Download File
    </button>
  );
}

4. Optimize Performance

Take advantage of TanStack Query's built-in optimization features:

const queryClient = new QueryClient({
  defaultOptions: {
    queries: {
      staleTime: 1000 * 60 * 5, // Data considered fresh for 5 minutes
      cacheTime: 1000 * 60 * 30, // Cache persists for 30 minutes
      refetchOnWindowFocus: false // Disable automatic refetching on window focus
    }
  }
});

Making the Decision

When deciding whether to implement TanStack Query in your server-component-heavy application, consider these key factors:

1. Application Complexity

If you're building a simple application with minimal client-side interactions, you might not need TanStack Query. As one developer mentioned, "I haven't worked on an app big/elaborate enough to benefit from react-query/tanstack-query." However, as your application grows and requires more dynamic data handling, TanStack Query's benefits become more apparent.

2. User Experience Requirements

Consider implementing TanStack Query if your application needs:

  • Instant UI updates with optimistic mutations

  • Sophisticated loading and error states

  • Background data synchronization

  • Complex caching strategies

3. Development Team Experience

TanStack Query can significantly improve code maintainability and reduce boilerplate. As noted in community discussions, "It helps in caching and clean code, as it gives all the state (loading error pending) that is helpful for me."

Conclusion

While server components have revolutionized how we approach data fetching in React applications, TanStack Query continues to provide significant value, even in server-component-heavy architectures. The key is understanding when and where to apply it strategically.

The library shines in scenarios requiring:

  • Complex client-side state management

  • Real-time data synchronization

  • Sophisticated caching strategies

  • Non-serializable data handling

  • Dynamic user interactions

Remember, it's not about choosing between server components and TanStack Query - it's about leveraging the strengths of both to build more robust, maintainable, and user-friendly applications.

Additional Resources

By thoughtfully combining server components with TanStack Query, you can create applications that offer the best of both worlds: excellent initial page loads and dynamic, responsive user interactions.

Raymond Yeh

Raymond Yeh

Published on 04 December 2024

Get engineers' time back from marketing!

Don't let managing a blog on your site get in the way of your core product.

Wisp empowers your marketing team to create and manage content on your website without consuming more engineering hours.

Get started in few lines of codes.

Choosing a CMS
Related Posts
Why Senior Developers Choose Tanstack Query Over Fetch and useEffect

Why Senior Developers Choose Tanstack Query Over Fetch and useEffect

Why rely on fetch and useEffect for data fetching? Discover why senior developers prefer Tanstack Query for better performance and maintainability.

Read Full Story
SSR with Remix using TanStack Query

SSR with Remix using TanStack Query

Explore SSR with Remix and TanStack Query in this article, focusing on setup, best practices, and real-world examples to boost SEO, enhance load times, and ensure smoother user interactions.

Read Full Story
Can React 19 Server Components and Server Actions Work Without Server Runtime?

Can React 19 Server Components and Server Actions Work Without Server Runtime?

Are Server Components worth the hype? Delve into scalability, complexity, and practical solutions for using React 19 features without a server runtime.

Read Full Story