TinaCMS vs ButterCMS

Compare TinaCMS and ButterCMS for your content needs. Find out what actual users are saying about each product and which one is best suited for you!

TinaCMS
TinaCMS
TinaCMS is an open-source, Git-backed headless content management system that empowers developers and content creators to collaborate seamlessly on a single platform, with real-time editing and version control.
ButterCMS
ButterCMS
Leading Content Management System (CMS) for Websites of All Sizes. Build SEO pages and mobile apps faster & easier with ButterCMS.

At a Glance

Quick overview of key features differences between TinaCMS and ButterCMS. Click on any feature to read more details.

FeatureTinaCMSButterCMS
Basic Features
Hosting Option
Cloud & Self-hosted
Cloud Only
Content Modeling
Blog on Subdomain
Blog on Subdirectory
Marketer Experience
Mobile-first Experience
Limited
Automatic Content Linking
Automatic CTA Linking
Engage with Comments
Multi-tenancy
Limited
Read all reviews from marketers
Developer Experience
Ease of Integration
Medium
Easy
Custom React Components
Full Text Search
Limited
Starter Kits
(2 kits)
(3 kits)
Read all reviews from developers
Looking for a better alternative to TinaCMS & ButterCMS? Try Wisp.
Wisp is the best solution for blogging. Try it free today!

What Users Say

See what users who have used TinaCMS and ButterCMS have to say about their overall experience with the product.

TinaCMS's Key Strengths

Read what users love about TinaCMS.

ButterCMS's Key Strengths

Read what users love about ButterCMS.

TinaCMS's Key Issues

Read what issues users have with TinaCMS.

ButterCMS's Key Issues

Read what issues users have with ButterCMS.

What Marketers & Content Creators Say

Hear from the users who uses TinaCMS and ButterCMS daily about their experience with the editors.

TinaCMS's Editorial Experience Highlights

What marketers love about TinaCMS's editor.

ButterCMS's Editorial Experience Highlights

What marketers love about ButterCMS's editor.

TinaCMS's Editorial Experience Issues

What marketers dislike about TinaCMS's editor.

ButterCMS's Editorial Experience Issues

What marketers dislike about ButterCMS's editor.

Mobile Editing

Find out how the platforms handle the mobile-first experience for the new generation of workforce on the move.

TinaCMS:
Limited Mobile Experience

TinaCMS has basic mobile editing capabilities but lacks a fully optimized mobile editor experience.

"Try Tina CMS, specifically with Tina cloud. I'm building a site out right now and the mobile editing experience is very straightforward."
Source
"Using Tina to edit content is, unfortunately, where the rough edges start to show. I started trying to write this post on my phone... the interface is clearly not meant for mobile screen sizes."
Source
"TinaCMS now supports various screen sizes and mobile devices, including iOS and Android. Whether you’re on the go, or at your desk, editing your content has never been more intuitive."
Source
ButterCMS:
Mobile-First Experience

ButterCMS supports a mobile-first experience optimizing content creation on mobile devices.

"A Mobile Content Management System (CMS) is a centralized data store that allows managing content for multiple platforms."
Source
"Butter makes CMS jobs faster with our intuitive content modeling and easy to integrate content API."
Source
"The Customizable WYSIWYG editor provides you with a content editing experience where the content resembles the appearance that will be displayed on your live site."
Source
"This centralized approach simplifies integration for developers, as they always deal with the same APIs and content models, regardless of the channel."
Source

Automatic Content Linking

Find out if the platform supports automatic linking of related content to help user discover more content without additional manual effort from the marketer. This automatically create topical clusters of content and is essential for SEO.

TinaCMS:
No Automatic Content Linking

TinaCMS does not include an automatic related blog feature for linking content. Manual linking is possible but not automated.

"Easiest CMS to set up with Astro : r/astrojs"
Source
"I also use TinaCMS for writing Blog post but it's way better than Tina CMS."
Source
"Each item in your collections array represents its own entity. In the above example, we defined a post collection."
Source
"Defining "collections". In the above example, we defined a post collection, and set its path as content/posts."
Source
ButterCMS:
No Automatic Content Linking

ButterCMS does not support automatic related blog linking for SEO; internal linking must be done manually.

"ButterCMS does not currently offer automated features for related content linking."
Source
"Blog posts are predefined pages with a pre-defined field that allows you to get a blog quickly connected with your site via built-in optimized SEO."
Source
"ButterCMS lacks an automatic process to link related blog posts; such linking must be handled manually."
Source

Automatic CTA Linking

Find out if the platform supports automatic display of Call-to-Actions using AI to help users take actions that are relevant to the content they are reading.

TinaCMS:
No Automatic CTA Linking

TinaCMS does not support automatic linking of CTAs based on content; only manual linking is possible.

"Tina does not provide a feature for automatic call-to-action linking."
Source
"Call to action buttons; Call to action panels are supported, but automatic linking is not mentioned."
Source
"TinaCMS's Headless CMS Features do not include automatic call-to-action suggestions."
Source
ButterCMS:
No Automatic CTA Linking

ButterCMS does not support automatic CTA linking; marketers must manually assign CTAs in their content.

"ButterCMS lacks features for automatic linking of call-to-action blocks; users must manage placements manually."
Source
"The platform does not mention support for automatically linking call-to-action elements."
Source
"Marketers are responsible for manually selecting and placing CTAs in the ButterCMS blog engine."
Source

Comments

Find out if the platform supports comments from your users to improve user engagement. This is often a great way to collect feedback and user emails.

TinaCMS:
No Comments Supported

TinaCMS does not offer built-in commenting feature for public content. Custom implementations are possible but not out-of-the-box.

"TinaCMS has not integrated a traditional commenting feature like WordPress; it allows editing and review processes but does not allow public comments on articles."
Source
"Currently, TinaCMS does not support external commenting features for user-generated feedback on blogs or articles."
Source
ButterCMS:
No Comments Supported

ButterCMS does not natively support commenting; users must integrate third-party tools like Disqus.

"Adding this comments feature and setting it up is really easy to do. We recommend using existing third-party tools for this as they're great for managing your blog comments."
Source
"Easily kickoff approval workflows, leave comments, assign owners and add due dates."
Source

Multi-tenancy

Find out if the platform supports managing multiple clients or projects within a single account. This is useful for agencies, multi-client or multi-project scenarios.

TinaCMS:
Limited Multi-tenancy

TinaCMS offers multi-tenancy capabilities but requires manual implementation for user management and project collaborations.

"For a more advanced branching and Pull-Request workflow, checkout TinaCloud's editorial workflow (only available on Business and Enterprise plans)."
Source
"Tina supports using external media providers, however a light backend media handler needs to be setup/hosted by the user."
Source
ButterCMS:
Multi-tenancy Supported

ButterCMS supports multi-tenancy, enabling users to manage multiple client accounts from a single dashboard.

"Manage multiple brands and languages easily"
Source
"A multisite CMS is designed to handle a growing network of sites... ButterCMS allows you to create and manage multiple sites."
Source
"Built-in multi-tenant capabilities."
Source

What Developers Say

Hear from developers who've integrated and built on TinaCMS and ButterCMS about their experiences.

Ease of Integrating TinaCMS:
Medium
Users report mixed experiences with integrating TinaCMS; some find it straightforward while others face challenges.
Ease of Integrating ButterCMS:
Easy
Integration with ButterCMS is straightforward, especially for developers familiar with APIs.

TinaCMS's DX Highlights

What developers love about building with TinaCMS.

ButterCMS's DX Highlights

What developers love about building with ButterCMS.

TinaCMS's DX Issues

What developers dislike about building with TinaCMS.

ButterCMS's DX Issues

What developers dislike about building with ButterCMS.

Content Modelling

Find out how developers model and manage their content with the platform with key highlights and limitations.

TinaCMS:
Customisable Content Types

TinaCMS supports content modeling, allowing custom content types and various fields.

"Tina uses a "content-modeling as code" approach, allowing developers to define the shape of their content."
Source
"Tina contains multiple field types like string, number, boolean, image, object, etc. that help in content modeling."
Source
"TinaCMS allows for real-time visual editing and has a robust content modeling schema that enhances block-based editing."
Source
"TinaCMS provides flexible content modeling features allowing developers to create custom content types."
Source
"Tina CMS is highlighted as a notable Git-based content management system that excels in content modeling."
Source
ButterCMS:
Customisable Content Types

ButterCMS supports content modeling with features like custom fields, page types, and collections.

"Easily manage all of your content types from one centralized dashboard. Butter makes CMS jobs faster with our intuitive content modeling."
Source
"ButterCMS is an easy to use tool for content management, allowing for seamless content modeling."
Source
"Butter allows you to create flexible page layouts and easily reorder them, supporting advanced content modeling."
Source

Custom React Components

Find out if the platform supports custom React components to go beyond the basic HTML components for content.

TinaCMS:
Custom React Components Supported

TinaCMS supports custom React components via the ui.component property in field definitions.

"A custom component can be passed and rendered by setting the ui.component property on a field. This component completely overrides the original component."
Source
"The first approach involves defining a React component and passing it into the component property of a field definition."
Source
"Tina also provides a variety of pre-built components. To specify these, the ui.component property should be configured with the string name of the registered field plugin."
Source
ButterCMS:
Custom React Components Supported

ButterCMS allows marketers to integrate custom React components into their content editor.

"Reusable React components are those components that are pure and predictable... Integrating React components with ButterCMS."
Source
"Now that we have launched our Components and Component Picker feature, we have a more efficient way to enable your marketers to insert custom HTML snippets..."
Source
TinaCMS:
Full Text Search Supported

TinaCMS supports full text search using search-index allowing content searches across multiple fields.

"TinaCMS provides built-in search functionality for content. This is useful for allowing editors to quickly finding content in a site."
Source
"Search is not currently supported in self-hosted Tina."
Source
"The self-hosted backend does not currently have endpoints to support search functionality."
Source
ButterCMS:
Limited Search

ButterCMS supports full-text search but currently only via API without direct audio input capabilities.

"ButterCMS allows searching through created blogs and pages using keywords."
Source
"It is important to note that ButterCMS does not currently support the use of audio input when searching for data."
Source
"Full Text Search. Search for specific words or phrases within a document or across multiple types."
Source

Starter Kits

Discover starter kits and templates to help you get started with the platform.

TinaCMS:
Available

TinaCMS offers starter kits for Next.js and Astro integration.

(Expand section to see a list of TinaCMS templates and starter kits.)

ButterCMS:
Available

ButterCMS provides various starter kits for Angular, Django, Next.js, etc.

(Expand section to see a list of ButterCMS templates and starter kits.)

Pricing & Plans

Compare the prices of TinaCMS and ButterCMS.

TinaCMS's Pricing
Free
$0 / month
- 2 Users
- 2 Roles
- Community Support
Team
$29 / month
- 3 Users
- 2 Roles
- Team Support
- Up to 10 Users
- $9/additional seat
Team Plus
$49 / month
- 5 Users
- 2 Roles
- Team Support
- Up to 20 Users
- $15/additional seat
- Editorial Workflow
- AI Features (Beta)
Business
$299 / month
- 20 Users
- 3 Roles (Beta)
- Business Support
- No User Limit
- $18/additional seat
- Editorial Workflow
- AI Features (Beta)
- API (Beta)
Enterprise
$0 / custom
- Custom Users
- Custom Roles
- Enterprise Support
- No User Limit
- Variable user pricing
- Custom Editorial Workflow
- AI Features (Beta)
- API (Beta)
- SSO
ButterCMS's Pricing
Micro
$119 / month
- 3 Users
- 5 Pages
- 50 Blog Posts
- 50 Collection Items
- WordPress Migration
- 3 Roles
Startup
$239 / month
- Unlimited Users
- 50 Pages
- 300 Blog Posts
- 500 Collection Items
- Components
- 3 Roles
Small Business
$449 / month
- Unlimited Users
- 100 Pages
- 600 Blog Posts
- 1000 Collection Items
- 5 Locales
- Image Editor
- Priority Support
- 3 Roles
Enterprise + Agency
$0 / custom
- Enterprise-class SLA
- Workflows
- Multiple Environments
- Sites+
- Write API
- Locale Permissions
- Video Support
- Solution Engineers and Agency Partners
- Custom roles
Free Developer Plan
$0 / month
- For personal non-commercial usage and trying us out. Just add an attribution link back to us.

Compare with other technologies

Looking for a better alternative to TinaCMS & ButterCMS? Try Wisp.
Wisp is the best solution for blogging. Try it free today!