Content Collections vs Magnolia

Compare Content Collections and Magnolia for your content needs. Find out what actual users are saying about each product and which one is best suited for you!

Content Collections
Content Collections
Transform your content into type-safe data collections with seamless integration and powerful validation, ensuring accuracy and a delightful developer experience.
Magnolia
Magnolia
With Magnolia, unify your content, customer data, and legacy tech to build engaging websites, portals, and apps at scale. Empower your content teams with AI and enterprise-level security.

What Users Say

See what users who have used Content Collections and Magnolia have to say about their overall experience with the product.

Content Collections's Key Strengths

Read what users love about Content Collections.

Magnolia's Key Strengths

Read what users love about Magnolia.

Content Collections's Key Issues

Read what issues users have with Content Collections.

Magnolia's Key Issues

Read what issues users have with Magnolia.

Looking for a better alternative to Content Collections & Magnolia? Try Wisp.
Wisp is the best solution for blogging. Try it free today!

What Marketers & Content Creators Say

Hear from the users who uses Content Collections and Magnolia daily about their experience with the editors.

Content Collections's Editorial Experience Highlights

What marketers love about Content Collections's editor.

Magnolia's Editorial Experience Highlights

What marketers love about Magnolia's editor.

Content Collections's Editorial Experience Issues

What marketers dislike about Content Collections's editor.

Magnolia's Editorial Experience Issues

What marketers dislike about Magnolia's editor.

Mobile Editing

Find out how the platforms handle the mobile-first experience for the new generation of workforce on the move.

Content Collections:
Mobile-First Experience

Wisp and Contentful support mobile-first experiences for content creation on mobile devices.

"Wisp was built from the ground up with mobile users in mind."
Source
"Contentful delivers content through a well-documented RESTful JSON-based API, which makes it fairly simple to get content from the backend."
Source
Magnolia:
Mobile-First Experience

Magnolia CMS supports mobile-first experience with a focus on creating content on mobile devices.

"Focused on delivering modern UX designs with a mobile-first mindset."
Source
"Start building responsive, mobile-first experience sites using web components with React, Angular or Vue."
Source
"Focus then shifted to mobile first, omni-channel experience, personalisation, loyalty and analytics."
Source
"Their rebuild of the software for a tablet and mobile first design."
Source

Automatic Content Linking

Find out if the platform supports automatic linking of related content to help user discover more content without additional manual effort from the marketer. This automatically create topical clusters of content and is essential for SEO.

Content Collections:
No Automatic Content Linking

The CMS does not support automated internal linking of related blog posts based on content similarity.

"You can define a collection from a set of data that is structurally similar."
Source
"We can manually add blogs one by one into the section and include a button that directs to the relevant URL."
Source
"Webflow Collections allow you to create groups of content but do not automate related content linking."
Source
Magnolia:
Unknown

The feature of automatic related blog linking is unclear from the available documentation and sources.

"No specific mention of automatic related blog linking found."
Source
"The AI Accelerator module mentions automation in content generation, but not specifically for related blogs."
Source
"Tagging functionality is available, but no clear automatic related linking feature noted."
Source

Automatic CTA Linking

Find out if the platform supports automatic display of Call-to-Actions using AI to help users take actions that are relevant to the content they are reading.

Content Collections:
No Automatic CTA Linking

Content Collections does not support automated linking for CTAs; this feature is generally missing in most CMS products.

"Content Collections is all about delivering a delightful developer experience, lacking automatic CTA linking."
Source
"Standard CMS features include manually linking CTAs without automation."
Source
"Explained auto interlinking in Magento but does not mention CTA linking features."
Source
Magnolia:
Manual CTA Linking

Magnolia offers AI features that assist in automatic content creation, but specific CTA linking is not detailed.

"Magnolia’s AI Accelerator brings flexibility and composability to AI in digital experiences, by supporting connections to any generative AI engines to speed up content creation."
Source
"Magnolia equips you with powerful tooling and an easy to use interface so that you can work more effectively and launch experiences faster."
Source
"This feature was experimental and relied on outdated and unmaintained libraries."
Source

Comments

Find out if the platform supports comments from your users to improve user engagement. This is often a great way to collect feedback and user emails.

Content Collections:
Comments Supported

Webflow CMS supports commenting via a paid add-on with built-in moderation features.

"Supercharge your Webflow CMS with comments that let people interact with your Collection content."
Source
"However, this permission does not allow visitors to update existing items or their field values."
Source
"When you create Collections in the Webflow CMS, you can add Collection items manually."
Source
Magnolia:
Comments Supported

Magnolia CMS supports commenting with moderation, email notifications, and anonymous comments.

"This module offers commenting features as well as the possibility of liking or disliking comments. You can moderate comments or mark as author’s favourite."
Source

Multi-tenancy

Find out if the platform supports managing multiple clients or projects within a single account. This is useful for agencies, multi-client or multi-project scenarios.

Content Collections:
Limited Multi-tenancy

Statamic supports multiple sites but is not intended for multi-tenant applications.

"I'm currently thinking of having a content collection called Organization, with a relation to an Admin User (User type, admin role)."
Source
"Strapi (which you can trick into multitenancy but it's not out of the box and, unfortunately, I can't get it to work)"
Source
"Payload has a multi-tenancy feature but requires significant setup."
Source
"The multi-tenancy feature lets you segregate content in CRX based on organization."
Source
"Statamic's multi-site capabilities are designed to manage a single site or site network with multiple localizations."
Source
Magnolia:
Multi-tenancy Supported

Magnolia supports multi-tenancy, allowing agencies to manage multiple client sites with separate configurations.

"Multi-tenancy and the ability to share content assets - while also being able to configure access on a per-tenant basis - is crucial in today's..."
Source
"With Magnolia's multi-site, multi-language and multi-tenancy capabilities, you can centrally manage your network of franchises, country sites or subsidiary websites."
Source
"Using the Multisite module, you can set up and run multiple websites with different domains and languages from one Magnolia installation."
Source

What Developers Say

Hear from developers who've integrated and built on Content Collections and Magnolia about their experiences.

Ease of Integrating Content Collections:
Medium
Integration can be complex due to documentation issues and managing assets alongside content.
Ease of Integrating Magnolia:
Medium
Integration is moderately complex, requiring various skills and understanding APIs.

Content Collections's DX Highlights

What developers love about building with Content Collections.

Magnolia's DX Highlights

What developers love about building with Magnolia.

Content Collections's DX Issues

What developers dislike about building with Content Collections.

Magnolia's DX Issues

What developers dislike about building with Magnolia.

Content Modelling

Find out how developers model and manage their content with the platform with key highlights and limitations.

Content Collections:
Customisable Content Types

Content Collections supports content modelling with customizable schemas and validation via Zod.

"Transform your content into type-safe data collections, providing useful utilities for data fetching and parsing."
Source
"Content Collections uses a schema to define the fields of a collection. Computed fields can be added with the transform function."
Source
"The schema will validate the title and summary fields, ensuring data integrity."
Source
Magnolia:
Customisable Content Types

Magnolia CMS supports content modelling with customizable content types and properties.

"Magnolia allows you to manage all your content and media in one place. Flexible content modeling."
Source
"A content model defines the structure and attributes of content for a specific project, including content types."
Source
"The Magnolia Content Types module is a tool to define the content model in Magnolia, creating a shared understanding across the domains."
Source
"A model definition describes the properties of a content type, including fields and relationships."
Source

Custom React Components

Find out if the platform supports custom React components to go beyond the basic HTML components for content.

Content Collections:
Custom React Components Supported

Payload CMS supports custom React components in collections, enabling rich content integration.

"Swap in your own React components to be used within this Collection."
Source
"Decap CMS exposes two constructs globally to allow you to create components inline."
Source
"The same object is also the default export if you import Decap CMS as an npm module."
Source
"Learn how to embed HubSpot forms in ButterCMS using a custom React component."
Source
Magnolia:
Custom React Components Supported

Custom React components are supported through the Magnolia React Editor allowing dynamic content management.

"The Magnolia React Editor provides a lightweight, fully-featured library connecting React projects with the WYSIWYG authoring experience."
Source
"Magnolia React Templating allows you to use React JSX Components in Magnolia templates."
Source
"Components render content entered by editors in dialogs, supporting nested components."
Source

Full Text Search

Find out if the platform supports full text search across multiple fields to help users find content quickly.

Content Collections:
Full Text Search Supported

Contentful supports full-text search across multiple fields, enhancing search capabilities.

"Full-text search is case insensitive and might return more results than expected. A query will ignore search tokens with less than 2 characters."
Source
"In Contentful, full-text search terms are left anchored. This means that when you, for example, search for 'house,' we will convert it into the."
Source
"In Contentful's GraphQL API you can do searching within different fields with collection filters. Equivalent to full-text searching."
Source
"Contentful does include some intriguing full-text search capabilities out-of-the-box that searches across all fields."
Source
Magnolia:
Full Text Search Supported

Fully supports full-text search across all content with real-time results customization.

"Magnolia’s search works using the Lucene algorithm where by default all properties mentioned in the index-rule receive a boost value of 1.0."
Source
"The Find Bar allows you to search across all content search inside and outside Magnolia (federated search, enterprise search). The search covers all Magnolia and custom-content apps, assets and pages."
Source
"It offers powerful full-text search across all your content and provides a starting point for many tasks."
Source

Starter Kits

Discover starter kits and templates to help you get started with the platform.

Content Collections:
Available

Content Collections offers starter kits and templates through Acquia and Astro.

(Expand section to see a list of Content Collections templates and starter kits.)

Magnolia:
Available

Magnolia CMS has several starter kits available for developers.

(Expand section to see a list of Magnolia templates and starter kits.)

Pricing & Plans

Compare the prices of Content Collections and Magnolia.

Content Collections's Pricing
Standard
$5 / month
- Content import
- Type-safe data validation
- Access to API
Pro
$15 / month
- All Standard features
- Advanced validation options
- Support for custom transformations
Enterprise
$30 / month
- All Pro features
- Dedicated support
- Custom pricing options
Magnolia's Pricing
DX Cloud
$6000 / month
- Fully managed dedicated infrastructure
- Customizable
- Scalable
- Supports up to 99.9% uptime
- Multiple SLA packages
DX Core
$3500 / month
- Self-hosted
- Full control over infrastructure
- Multi-site support
- Seamless scalability
- Custom modules and integrations

Compare with other technologies

Looking for a better alternative to Content Collections & Magnolia? Try Wisp.
Wisp is the best solution for blogging. Try it free today!